Image: Toll BrothersMarsh Harbor
From $1,676,995
Gated, on the Intracoastal marsh, with a community dock.
Updated November 2026
Read the guideUpdated November 2026

SilverLeaf is a large master-planned community in St. Johns County with a St. Augustine address, near World Golf Village. It ranked among the 20 best-selling master-planned communities in the country in 2025, according to RCLCO figures published by NewHomeSource.
Several builders sell here at the same time, including ICI Homes, David Weekley Homes, Toll Brothers, Lennar and Dream Finders Homes, so you can compare single-family homes and townhomes across a wide range of sizes and prices in one place.
Residents share resort-style pools, clubhouses, a banquet hall, tennis and pickleball courts, sports fields, splash pads, a dog park and walking trails, and thousands of acres are set aside as nature preserve.
SilverLeaf has a master HOA plus neighborhood dues that vary. David Weekley Homes lists $1,200 a year for the master association and $1,000 a year for its Evergreen Island neighborhood. We'll confirm the total for any home you're considering.
As of November 2026, builder prices start in the upper $300,000s at Toll Brothers' Newbrook, $466,900 at David Weekley's Evergreen Island and $494,900 for ICI Homes, with larger homes above $1 million.
Builders and the county's official tourism guide say SilverLeaf homes have no CDD fees. There is a master HOA plus neighborhood dues.
Visit St. Augustine lists Wards Creek Elementary, Pacetti Bay Middle, and Allen D. Nease and Tocoi Creek high schools. Zoning varies by address, so confirm with St. Johns County schools.
Image: Toll BrothersFrom $1,676,995
Gated, on the Intracoastal marsh, with a community dock.
Updated November 2026
Read the guide
Image: Toll BrothersFrom $1,449,995
Just 20 homes, gated, near TPC Sawgrass.
Updated November 2026
Read the guide
Image: David Weekley HomesFrom $1.8 million
Final phase of 80-foot homesites in Nocatee.
Updated November 2026
Read the guidePricing, plans and availability are from the builder's published information as of November 2026 and can change at any time. Carrie & Co. is not affiliated with the builder.